Most Americans say ICE has ‘gone too far’ in new poll

Key Takeaways

Public disapproval of ICE tactics has significantly increased to 65% of Americans.
President Trump's approval stands at 39%, indicating a vulnerable political position.
The economy and lowering prices remain the top concern for 54% of Americans.
Independent voters are increasingly disapproving of Trump's immigration and foreign policies.
Republican voters remain highly tribal, defending Trump despite specific policy details.

An NPR/PBS News/Marist Poll reveals 65% of Americans believe Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) actions have gone too far, an 11-point increase since last summer.
Domenico Montanaro noted this shift is influenced by recent media coverage, including the deaths of two American citizens.
Ashley Lopez highlighted that independent voters, despite generally favoring border security, have shifted their perception due to recent ICE tactics and specific incidents, impacting President Trump's standing.

The discussion identifies "culture" and tribalism as primary motivators for Republican voters, superseding concerns about economic anxiety or ICE tactics.
Key groups like independents, Latinos, and voters under 30, who were crucial in Trump's 2016 victory due to the economy, have now abandoned him in polls.
Nearly 6 in 10 Americans view protests against ICE tactics as legitimate, revealing polarization with 85% of Democrats and 65% of Independents agreeing, while 75% of Republicans deem them unlawful.

President Trump's overall approval rating stands at 39% according to recent poll results, indicating a vulnerable political position.
The economy, particularly lowering prices, remains the top priority for 54% of Americans, with controlling immigration a distant second at 22%.
While 44% of Republicans prioritize immigration, Democrats and Independents overwhelmingly favor addressing prices.

Focus group observations confirm voters, including independents and swing voters, are concerned about the economy and affordability, feeling Trump is distracted.
59% of Americans disapprove of Trump's economic job performance, and 56% believe his policies like tariffs harm the economy.
On foreign policy, 56% of people disapprove of Trump's job performance, and two-thirds oppose the US taking control of Greenland.
72% of Americans believe the president should consult Congress before military action, a stance Republicans do not share.

Poll trends showing consistent disapproval from independents and Democrats, while Republicans remain supportive, challenge the White House's messaging.
The administration is aware of these numbers and attempting pivots, evidenced by discussions around immigration enforcement and a proposed drawdown of agents.
The White House plans to emphasize the economy weekly, but speeches often lack focus due to Trump's tendency to deviate from teleprompters.
This lack of consistent focus on the economy, coupled with general chaos, makes it difficult to convey kitchen-table issues to voters.