My First Million

5 Startups That Looked Dumb—Until They Were Worth Billions

Overview

Content

Underestimating Opportunities and Overestimating Risks

Shopify Case Study

- Valued at $20 million - Had $5 million in revenue - Had 10,000 total customers - Generated $132 million in Gross Merchandise Value (GMV)

- Worth approximately $130-140 billion - Adds over 10,000 paid customers weekly - Has multiple million customers - Generates close to a trillion dollars in GMV

- Bessemer's best-case exit scenario was $400 million - Actual value is now 350+ times their initial projection - Demonstrates massive potential of technology platforms that are initially underestimated

Personal Examples of Underestimated Opportunities

- Initially thought the market was too small - Now multiple meditation apps are billion-dollar companies

- Initially dismissed as a niche "sexting" platform - Didn't see its broader potential

- Compared it to Couchsurfing, thought it was unambitious - Now a $100 billion company - One out of every $30 spent on travel in America is on Airbnb

- Initially saw it as a niche black car service for rich people in San Francisco - Didn't recognize its broader potential

- Dismissed as a distraction when an employee mentioned his daughter using it - Didn't see the potential of short-form video content

Investment Challenges and Philosophies

- Underestimating market sizes - Difficulty comprehending exponential growth and large numbers - Struggling to understand long-term value projections

- Invest in "Park Avenue" of startups (top-tier, seemingly expensive assets) - Belief that investing in the best assets at high valuations can pay off long-term - Willing to invest in high-value companies like OpenAI at $250 billion valuation

- Bitcoin is like "digital Manhattan" - Scarcity and rarity make it valuable - Focus on owning the best, most limited asset rather than cheaper alternatives

Risk Management Perspectives

- Keeping oneself "in the game" financially - References the Kelly criterion as a risk management principle - Warren Buffett's philosophy of not risking what you need for what you don't want

- Extremely successful entrepreneurs like Elon Musk operate differently - Taking extreme risks isn't necessarily wise, despite potential achievements - Risk of ruin can be financial or reputational - For some entrepreneurs, losing money isn't a true "ruin" scenario

OpenAI Origin Story Insights

- Estimated training costs at $100 million+ per model - Elon proposed funding OpenAI through Tesla's commercial profits - Other founders rejected this idea due to concerns about control

- Microsoft offered multi-billion dollar compute resources - Elon was dismissive of the Microsoft partnership - Sam Altman explored the possibility of an Initial Coin Offering (ICO)

- Strongly opposed the ICO, calling it "reputationally disastrous" - Threatened to remove his name from the project if an ICO was pursued - Willing to take calculated risks, but selective about which risks to undertake

Observations About Exceptional Individuals

- Initially avoided endorsing candidates - Later became more politically active, potentially due to regulatory pressures or perceived attacks on capitalism

Market Size Analysis and Disruption

- Bill Gurley's blog post "How to Miss by a Mile" critiqued a NYU professor's valuation of Uber at $17 billion - Traditional market analysis often fails to account for transformative innovations

- Critical distinction between precision and accuracy in financial forecasting - New products can fundamentally reshape market potential beyond historical trends - Traditional market size predictions can dramatically underestimate technological disruption

- AT&T commissioned McKinsey to forecast cell phone market size - McKinsey predicted 900,000 cell phone users by 2000 - Actual cell phone usage was 109 billion - significantly higher than the prediction - AT&T's failure to invest in cell phones early led to a $12 billion acquisition mistake

Investment Philosophy Differences

- Disruptive technologies often create entirely new markets, not just capture existing market share - Example: Uber in San Francisco expanded the transportation market beyond traditional taxi services - New products can grow markets to 3x the size of existing categories - Aaron Levy's quote highlights the danger of sizing new markets based on existing incumbent markets

- Willingness to be wrong multiple times - Optimistic perspective - Ability to recognize market expansion potential - Understanding that past performance doesn't predict future innovation

Technology Waves and Market Transformation

- Software 1.0: Installing software on physical servers/CDs - Software 2.0: Cloud/SaaS model - Current Wave: AI

- Cloud market grew to $400 billion, significantly larger than the original $350 billion software market - AI is expected to be even more transformative, potentially disrupting both software and labor markets

- Can replace both software and human labor - Predicted to potentially exceed the size of current cloud and labor markets - Likely to create entirely new use cases and market opportunities

Personal AI Learning Approach

- Avoids constant information overload - Researches AI when he has specific problems to solve - Uses an "intermittent fasting" style of AI learning

- Conducted an "AI hack week" to deeply explore AI capabilities - Compares AI learning to email management - batching information intake - Believes he has a higher risk of under-investing in AI knowledge than over-investing

- Tracking piano practice - Analyzing health/lab results - Solving specific problems

Entrepreneurs Who Underestimated Their Own Market Potential

- WhatsApp CEO Jan Coombe: Initially just wanted to improve messaging - Sarah Blakely (Spanx founder): Started with modest goal of side income - Nokia's mobile gaming head: Dismissed mobile gaming as a small add-on (now a $120 billion market) - Domino's CEO (2010): Viewed delivery as mere convenience (now dramatically expanded)

- Restaurants are now primarily delivery-focused, with some estimates suggesting 70% of order volume from delivery - Entrepreneurs like Brian Chesky (Airbnb) and Elon Musk emphasize creating fundamentally different products over initial market size

More from My First Million

Explore all episode briefs from this podcast

View All Episodes →

Listen smarter with PodBrief

Get AI-powered briefs for all your favorite podcasts, plus a daily feed that keeps you informed.

Download on the App Store