All-In vs My First Million: Which Business Podcast is Better?

All-In and My First Million are two of the most popular business podcasts. Both cover startups, tech, and markets—but they approach it very differently. Here's how to choose.

Quick Comparison

All-In Podcast: The Debate Format

Hosts & Format

Four tech investors with different viewpoints debate current events:

• Chamath Palihapitiya: Social Capital founder, contrarian investor
• Jason Calacanis: Angel investor, startup advisor
• David Sacks: PayPal mafia, Craft Ventures
• David Friedberg: Founder Institute, scientist-turned-investor

What Makes It Unique

• Multiple perspectives: You hear 4 different takes on every topic
• High-level analysis: Deep dives into policy, markets, AI
• No filter: They argue openly, disagree, push back
• Weekly summary: Covers all major business/tech news from the week

Typical Topics

• AI development and regulation
• Economic policy and inflation
• Tech company earnings and strategy
• Startup valuations and funding
• Political impact on business

My First Million: The Idea Factory

Hosts & Format

Two entrepreneurs brainstorm business ideas and interview founders:

• Shaan Puri: Former Twitch executive, serial entrepreneur
• Sam Parr: The Hustle founder (sold to HubSpot)

What Makes It Unique

• Business idea brainstorms: Actionable startup concepts every episode
• Shorter, more frequent: 2-3 episodes per week, 45-60 min each
• Operator focus: How to actually build and grow businesses
• Casual vibe: Feels like listening to friends talk business

Typical Topics

• Trending business opportunities
• Marketing and growth tactics
• Founder interviews and stories
• Emerging markets and niches
• How specific businesses make money

Head-to-Head Breakdown

Content Depth

All-In wins for: Market analysis, policy discussion, macro trends

My First Million wins for: Specific business ideas, tactical execution, trends

Actionability

All-In: Great for understanding "what's happening" but less "what to do about it"

My First Million: Literally gives you business ideas to steal and build

Entertainment Value

All-In: High-energy debates, tension between hosts, strong opinions

My First Million: Funny stories, casual banter, relatable entrepreneur struggles

Time Commitment

All-In: 60-90 min weekly (easier to keep up)

My First Million: 2-3x per week (more content, harder to stay current)

Who Should Listen to All-In?

Best For

• Investors tracking market trends
• People interested in tech + policy intersection
• Those who enjoy debate-style content
• Anyone wanting a weekly business/tech news summary
• Fans of contrarian takes and strong opinions

Skip If

• You want specific business ideas to execute
• You prefer short, tactical episodes
• Politics in business podcasts annoys you
• You're looking for beginner-friendly content

Who Should Listen to My First Million?

Best For

• Entrepreneurs looking for business ideas
• People interested in trends before they're mainstream
• Anyone who wants "what to build" not just "what's happening"
• Fans of founder stories and case studies
• Those who prefer casual, relatable content

Skip If

• You want deep policy or market analysis
• You prefer formal, structured episodes
• You can't keep up with 2-3 episodes per week
• You're more interested in investing than operating

Can You Listen to Both?

Yes! They complement each other well:

• All-In: Understand macro trends and what's happening in markets
• My First Million: Get specific ideas to capitalize on those trends

Suggested Approach

• Listen to All-In every week (it's only one 90-min episode)
• Pick 1-2 My First Million episodes per week based on topic
• Use episode summaries to decide which MFM episodes are worth your time

Episode Quality: Which is More Consistent?

All-In

Very consistent. Every episode follows the same format: news recap → deep dives → "science corner." You always know what you're getting.

My First Million

More variable. Some episodes are gold (amazing business ideas), others are less relevant. Worth checking summaries first.

The Verdict

Choose All-In if you want:

• Weekly business/tech news summary
• Multiple perspectives on major events
• Deep analysis over quick ideas
• Debate-style discussion

Choose My First Million if you want:

• Business ideas you can actually build
• Tactical growth and marketing strategies
• More frequent, shorter episodes
• Casual, entertaining business talk

Choose Both if you want:

• Complete business podcast diet
• Macro trends + micro tactics
• Investor perspective + operator perspective

Start Listening